The Grand Forest Beach Realty Company bought a 200-acre tract of the former Wright property from Dr. Joseph Esch and his wife, Gertrude Wright Esch, a granddaughter of Jabez Wright, in 1921 for $175,00. Known as the Grand Forest Beach Club, the land, which included the spacious Esch Mansion, was plotted and marketed to residents of the land-locked town of Mansfield, Ohio as a summer lake resort. Residents on both the north and south sides of Cleveland Road were awarded beach access in their deeds.